This is a collaborative wiki. We invite anyone who is interested to create an account and pitch in. Below are some notes where we keep track of needs and plans.
The main forum for discussing the development of Ethical EdTech is our public email discussion list. You can also participate in synchronous conversation at #ethicaledtech on Freenode IRC. We also host regular events.
Be sure to consult the About page for inclusion criteria and more on the spirit of the project.
- 1 Students
- 2 Adding pages to the wiki
- 3 Tools to be added
- 4 The Module: namespace
- 5 Issues and roadmap
Student participation in this project is essential to its success. Share your insights and experience about tools you've encountered in class and ideas for how technology can better meet your needs.
Get started by joining the conversation at the Student Voices page. Students should also feel free to contribute to any part of the Ethical EdTech wiki project.
Adding pages to the wiki
New pages that are not Tools should be preceded by ":Meta:" or another custom namespace.
Adding a new Tool page
- Go to the Page Template, click the gear button at the top-right, and click Edit
- Copy the full content of the page source
- Go to the URL of the tool you want to create: ethicaledtech.info/wiki/[Tool_name]
- Click the gear button at the top-right, and click Create
- Paste the content of the Template source into the empty field
For guidance, you can look at the source code of existing pages by clicking their Edit buttons.
Tools to be added
- RawGraphs: open-source, browser-based tool for data visualization
- KH Coder: open-source desktop software for qualitative data analysis and text mining
- Palladio: open-source, browser-based tool for exploring historical data
- Cytoscape: open-source bioinformatics software for network analysis
- TimelineJS: open-source KnightLab tool for creating interactive timelines (possible ethical issue: requires use of Google sheets)
- Lexos Visualizer: open source, browser-based tool for "lexomics" computational text mining
- SciLab: open-source alternative to MATLAB for statistical analysis and data visualization
- QGIS: open-source alternative to ArcGIS or other proprietary geographic information systems
- Omeka:Platform for sharing digital collections and creating media-rich online exhibits. Developed at George Mason University.
- Neatline: Platform for allowing students and scholars to tell stories with maps and timelines. Developed for Omeka.
- Drupal (linked from Scripto)
- Jupyter Notebook: Web application for creating and sharing documents with interactive code.
- Bak USA Atlas - education laptop made in Buffalo
- Raspberry Pi
- System76 - Made in Denver
- Tor and the onion browser
Not categorized yet
The Module: namespace
We now (as of 20190604) have a Module: namespace. This is designed for things like:
- Lesson plans (like a set of tools, readings, and assessments)
- Tool packages (like a set of tools that work well together for a particular purpose)
- Topic modules (like a batch of readings about surveillance capitalism)
So far, these haven't been implemented. Where shall we start?
Issues and roadmap
- Develop an Ethical EdTech syllabus that better organizes the material on Contribute and the Zotero group
- Set up pre-filled template for new page creation
- Consider re-orienting the navigation from being tool-centric to being practice-centric, perhaps by focusing on workflows, lesson plans, or packages of tools
- Specify "ethical" by defining a series of axes or criteria by which the tools are evaluated, such as: accessibility, privacy/security, transparency, commercialism, cost, control of data, usefulness outside of school
- Wiki design
- Modify the template to have a more appropriate, useful structure. "Related" might be redundant with the Categories.
- What's the easiest way to get logos into pages? Use WikiMedia Commons?
- Custom Design
- Need a logo (ico) and color scheme (here)
- A page outlining a few quick easy options for educators who don't have much time to try out new tools
- Set a maximum width for content and header bar
- When ready, tweet out to all included projects word that they're in here
Future of the project:
- How can we organize educators to help strengthen these platforms?
- What organizations might be interested in supporting this work?
- What forms of publication would advance our goals?
- How do we define our list of standards and goals?
- How can our values inform our participation in EdTech and other technology/pedagogy conferences? (Conference values statement)
Questions educators might ask ourselves related to ethical EdTech:
- How can we learn more about surveillance practices happening via educational technology on our campuses?
- How can we influence campus IT decisions?
- How do we offer students open-source tools and resources when they already use/rely on proprietary tools?
- How do we maintain an equitable classroom when students have different levels of access to technology & tech tools?
- When are data collection practices ethical? When giving personal data, what does actual consent versus coerced consent look like?
What challenges do you face in avoiding the use of technologies that practice unethical forms of user surveillance and control? List any social, technical, institutional or other challenges that come to mind.
- There is no easy-to-use alternative to Google Docs, which is useful for facilitating collaborative writing, peer review, and instructor feedback.
- Students may be more inclined to use the (often more user-friendly) tools they are already familiar with rather than learning how to use different tools.
- Creating classroom consciousness takes time and scaffolding - a difficult task in short terms with many students.
- Instructors may be prescribed access to specific technologies and institutionally asked or mandated to use them.
Outcomes and goals
What projects might emerge from this documentation effort?
- A campaign encouraging campuses to better support open as opposed to proprietary tools
- A package mixing VPS/Cloudron/etc. to make it easier for educators to deploy these tools
- A marketing cooperative of affiliated open projects
- Pedagogical tools/modules